回論壇首頁
論壇主選單 > 香港論壇 > Canon "L" 與 Nikon "ED" 一談
作者  
討論話題
 

iLL_le


網路會員

2004/04/07 00:09
器材: 其他 其他
小弟由第一日玩EOS開始,已很迷戀"L"鏡,但"L"並不便宜。反觀NIKON的ED鏡遍佈各價位,即使3千開頭,就可窺探ED迷人的實力。其實NIKON標了"ED"的鏡頭是否與CANON的"L"頭一樣帶給用家門一個畫質/色彩/品質肯定?

Seabook


網路會員

1) 2004/04/07 00:13 
L鏡 同 ED鏡都係低色散鏡片....

不過好似ED鏡係會吸左某一個Frequence既光而L鏡唔會...?

wkleung88


網路會員

2) 2004/04/07 00:26 
L鏡並不是鏡片.

iLL_le


網路會員

3) 2004/04/07 00:26 
yes,我明白NIKON的ED大致上等如CANON的UD。而"L"是包含UD、SuperUD、FL、研削式非球面鏡片。NIKON標上"ED"的都是較為高級的鏡,CANON標上"L"的也是較為高級的鏡。我是想知道是否一樣帶給用家門一個畫質/色彩/品質肯定?白點說是NIKON標上"ED"比較"腩";還是CANON標上"L"太嚴謹?

得罪各位...

RE:
不過好似ED鏡係會吸左某一個Frequence既光而L鏡唔會...?

我也不知道

jsklee


網路會員

4) 2004/04/07 00:30 
What do you think if the 50/1.4 is compared with the 28-70/2.8L?

iLL_le


網路會員

5) 2004/04/07 00:54 
Sorry,我明白50/1.4會比28-70的50好。我應補充zoom比zoom,prime比prime較為正確。

jsklee


網路會員

6) 2004/04/07 02:34 
I agree that L lens may be the best among the zoom at simiarly ranges, but if your reason of 迷戀"L"鏡 is for the resolution, then I should suggest you to go to the prime.

jsklee


網路會員

7) 2004/04/07 02:34 
sorry, "simiarly ranges" should be "similar ranges"

cocheuk


網路會員

8) 2004/04/07 03:46 
L means a lot of things besides optics.  There"s build quality, handling, etc...so don"t just focus on the image quality because it isn"t "everything".

Vincent★帝國天使


論壇版主

9) 2004/04/07 04:54 
Now we have EF 17-40/4.0 L and EF 70-200/4.0 L...


:)))

N記沒有特別整一個類似FA*/L/G的"高級/專業"系列,不過高級鏡頭大家都會分...

wlachan


網路會員

10) 2004/04/07 05:23 
I think people have tried to rationalize things which aren"t exactly compariable. Canon, Minolta and Pentax label their high end lenses as L, G and * respectively, while Nikon makes no such distinction. Now even mid-low end Nikkors have ED elements (or so they claimed). Also, regular lenses do not neceassily mean inferior quality, just not techanically special enough to carry such labels. I"d say "real" photohgraphers should not get too hook to this game.

Yuen_Vincent


網路會員

11) 2004/04/07 07:27 
I believe so
Is just the superior in price
I believe those things at first...(Like Asphereical lense, ED lens, etc)
But basically is the trick of firms to make more profit.

香港至*NET*超人


網路會員

12) 2004/04/07 10:57 
The Pentax * (green) is not indication of a special good lens.
It is a label of using a special ground glass type only. There
are dog lens in green* series, like SMC-A300/4.
ED of Nikon is also just an indication of using ED glass. There
are low price stuff using it, like AF70-300ED.
These special lens element may result in better optical performance
than general same range of lens. But than, you can"t compare apple
to orange.

By the way, if you need better optical forget Zoom is the first
step.

macroadster


網路會員

13) 2004/04/07 11:19 
據說 L = luxury

Vincent★帝國天使 wrote: Now we have EF 17-40/4.0 L and EF 70-200/4.0 L...

這兩支鏡是 L 鏡中 C/P 值最高的了,不太 luxury。

KhaKiKhaKi


網路會員

14) 2004/04/07 11:28 
點解冇人講minolta G鏡?
絕不比L鏡便宜~!

Vincent★帝國天使


論壇版主

15) 2004/04/07 11:30 
macroadster:

不太"L"不過便宜!
Haha

CKH


網路會員

16) 2004/04/07 11:45 
Canon 的"L" (紅色邊)應該等於 Nikon 的金邊,Nikon 的高級鏡都有金色邊......

香港至*NET*超人


網路會員

17) 2004/04/07 15:18 
NIKON冇ED鏡既鏡高唔高級?

jsklee


網路會員

18) 2004/04/07 15:27 
"L means a lot of things besides optics. There"s build quality, handling, etc...so don"t just focus on the image quality because it isn"t "everything"."

If your reason for buying the lens is for build quality, handling etc, then L lens would be good.  I just emphasis that if your reason for buying L lens is for resolution, then I agree superman that you should change to the prime.

For me, the reasons for buying lens could be divided into two: one is for use -- which means that I would put my emphasis on resolution.  In this case, I would choose prime.  

The other one is for collection.  No need to say, I would choose L lens.

jsklee


網路會員

19) 2004/04/07 15:28 
For sure is that I am just talking about the optics or optical performance of the lens.

I am not saying that you could not take good photos without good lens.

老中青


網路會員

20) 2004/04/07 16:39 
NIKON大部份手動鏡都冇ED鏡片,短過180mm的都沒有,唔通就冇高級鏡。
回上一層 第1頁 / 共4頁 到第 頁   下一頁   最末頁 1 2 3 4
手札小舖熱門商品
【台灣私房景點全集】共5冊,合購73折再贈進口黑卡
【我的夢幻人像鏡】2013最新增訂版!
【Nikon DX 達人聖經】手札聖經系列重出江湖!
【駕馭數位單眼相機】貫通攝影的最佳教本!
【2013攝影年鑑】年度新書隆重上市!
攝影家手札數位影像坊DV哈燒網KeyBuy藝廊論壇
服務信箱:242204 新莊副都心郵局第12信箱 │ 會員服務部:02-85215082(上班時間早上9點~下午6點) 和平東路三段276號 │ 廣告專線:0937-887229 │ 總瀏覽1166994148人 │ 線上1389人
攝影家手札科技有限公司 版權所有 © 2017 PhotoSharp All Rights Reserved. 非經許可,請勿任意轉載、出版本站內容