回論壇首頁
論壇主選單 > 器材版 - 類別: 數位單眼 > D200 VS D2X
作者  
討論話題
 

kuankuoyun2002


網路會員

2005/12/15 02:13
器材: Nikon 尼康 D200最新拍賣藝廊作品D200規格表
Swedish "Kamera & Bild" on the D200 vs D2x...

Further findings from their blog, when comparing D200 to D2x @100 ISO:


--- There's almost no difference between the two, despite the factor 3 in price.


--- You'll probably need A3-format before being able to see the minor edge of the D2x in sharpness.

--- Pictures from the two cams are so much alike, it's almost unreal, despite D2x being CMOS and D200 CCD.

--- Differences in sharpness is partly because of the difference in MP, but it also looks like the D200 might have a slightly stronger sensor filter (they're not sure about the filter, though).

--- There is, when it comes to image quality at low ISO, no real need to buy a D2x instead of a D200. At high ISO, the D200 will surpass its bigger brother by a WIDE margin.


LINK TO BLOG:

http://kamerabild.mkf.se/... .../20051214162333_ADF128.dbp.asp






--
Take care,
Jorgen

Probere necesse est.....
http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/read.asp?forum=1021&message=16270073

ckyik


網路會員

1) 2005/12/15 03:19 
看不懂那個網站
未知測試方式是否客觀
但只看一張相片就下結論有點膚淺
看測試圖的話
我倒覺得D2x還是比D200 sharp 一點點


http://kamerabild.mkf.se/ArticlePages/200512/14/20051214162333_ADF128/blogg-testbild-d2x_s.jpg

http://kamerabild.mkf.se/ArticlePages/200512/14/20051214162333_ADF128/blogg-testbild-d200_s.jpg

kuankuoyun2002


網路會員

2) 2005/12/15 13:48 
New D200 review from Japan

http://www.handy3.com/sikaworks/NikonD200/web-content/index.html

Babelfish version :-):

http://babelfish.altavista.com/... ...%2FNikonD200%2Fweb-content%2Findex.html

One interesting point is that dynamic range is seemed to be about 1/3-1/2 stop wider than D2X.
http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/read.asp?forum=1021&message=16262664

kuankuoyun2002


網路會員

3) 2005/12/15 14:01 
Translation by babelfish:

Nikon D200

Also the one which touches already being many, the ginger, after a long time the Kano report Nikon D200.
Of course, because the verification range beta machine is used,
The individual which actually is sold there is a possibility of differing.The actual 販 price 20 ten thousand Yen which Nikon which adhered to APS-C size built up are cut, the digital camera which you can use as professional use is sold on December 16th. The place where it is prepared carefully is enormous to the necessary lens not only the body, digital it is necessary for that, as a APS-C size.
With reality function as a camera it does not reach to Nikon D2X as expected, but it approaches ability of the especially pixel unit to D2X as a data, regarding in the dynamic range and as exceeded D2X, it is thought. You do not call the sub camera in that sense, the scene which participates as a certain semantic main camera is mainly supposed.
If it can have getting wise one end of the capability in this report, it is fortunate.Digital compare data verificationThis time several place where it should compare observe it specified. As for that the resolution impression, spectrum reflected quality, the dynamic range, color reproducibility, long haul exposure, high sensitivity quality, problem of the わ る noise which it waits in those. These while on the center by comparison with Nikon D2X it reports.The resolution impression check by the electric private school quality pixel chartKnowing electric private school quality pixel chart. Relatively the resolution impression, MTF quality well using the 35mmF2 lens where also the distortion of ク and around is little in the lens where I have this it photographed.
That red it is huge densely the part which is the っ て ON of 1 pixel, it becomes OFF, it photographs carefully. You observe whether some kind of processing is added to the shape which is worthy of to 1 pixel with this. When you see carefully, the chart of 2 pixels there is no problem almost, as for the chart of 4 pixels completely it understands that it is not problem. If very 3 pixels or more, is shape in the thinnest line where as for this with quality of the digital data, we would like to dissect, when 4 pixels or more is applied, that line, or shape is connected expanding to wherever, all right, with the notion that where you say.
First this phenomenon will be explained roughly. We assume that the straight line which just is worthy of to 1 pixel temporarily existed. When we assume, that this straight line, just had maintained verticality or horizontality, it can dissect that line securely with 1 ピクセ る. But, usually, exactly there are no times when it is piled up to 1 pixel, extend over 2 pixels and they mean to exist. When with it becomes, with also the line where the original line segment is deep-black, because it is recorded over 2 pixels, after all it becomes the line segment of 2 pixels of the grey.
In addition, if even a little it becomes slanted, it wanders 3 pixels, furthermore as a light grey record it means る thing. When it becomes the curved line where this is strong, furthermore as for needing 4 pixels you probably will understand simply.
It will try doing again to suppose the pixel to here that 1/4 is. Securely, the part which can be reproduced black are 2 pixels, or more as for the part of the grey as for the value which becomes 1/4, furthermore the grey the both ends has become small. When that happens, the thin line to be dissected securely, expanding using, because has been originally shape clear, if only enlargement method you are not wrong, it can expand cleanly.
As understood with this experiment, ON of 1 pixel, photographing the OFF chart normally, that 1 pixel to be piled up just, it is not the case that it can photograph. 3 or the fact that it dissects securely at the place of 4 pixels is actuality.
The fact that we would like to decide with the chart of 1 pixel, being about, very, how it correspo

kuankuoyun2002


網路會員

4) 2005/12/15 14:02 
The fact that we would like to decide with the chart of 1 pixel, being about, very, how it corresponds to this, resolution impossible part, is the part where each manufacturer has fought furiously.
Nikon D2XNikon D200As for the chart the left the part where it is surrounded with red 1 pixel, center 2 pixels, the chart where the bottom corresponds to 4 pixels is indicated with actual size. Nikon D2X applying in the resolution impression, the ぴ is the camera which is one result. Way the one whose pixel pitch of 1 pixel is detailed you understand even with reason above, in this case originally pixel pitch Nikon D2X 5.5 μ, as for the resolution impression is a certain expectation Nikon D200 7.3 μ compared to.
But it examines Nikon D200 well. Completely, saying, there is no inferiority, instead of, 1 pixel chart two putting, shape deteriorates, in the kind of part which becomes cause of moire has escaped to the grey beautifully. A little, when it does, somehow will dissect also the part where the shape where Nikon D2X which dies is not possible has been built up is discovered.
When in the reason where the open part of the image sensor is large, it compares to Nikon D2X the kana where the response for the part where spatial frequency is high becomes a little bad, with the fear which is said it had, but if you look at the completion of this chart, almost calling equality, it becomes inconvenient and it is improbable. It probably is the result of the low-pass filter to which, the reaction minuter shape than even 1 pixel (7.3 μ or less) vis-a-vis being beautiful, two makes this cross, furthermore becomes as one unit. When you look at the processing of the edge around 4 pixels, what does the fog and the hard completion understands well from Nikon D2X.
Spectrum reflected qualityNikon D2XNikon D200It surpasses to Nikon D2X which has fog beam established reputation in regard to the spectrum reflected quality by the near infrared rays also it is not inferior. Also this filter makes two of hot mirror type and dye type compete of heat wave absorption, above 700nano we cut the infrared component closely at the beautiful gradation, we hold down also the change by the illuminant to the maximum. The camera where near infrared rays measure is taken beautifully at Nikon is just Nikon D2X and Nikon D200 to here. You can call D200 even in this sense that it has the big advantage, vis-a-vis the camera below that.
This time also ultraviolet ray cutting was administered, the color due to the aberration of the lens "spread and" became the design which is held down. It reappears with the influence for the color which the shadow which absorbs the ultraviolet ray moderately, it seems that can hold down the holding down and chromatic aberration.
Low-pass and the ultraviolet ray removal which it crosses, the filter of near infrared rays cutting is collected by all one, the case where light is received holds down the fact that the response decreases.
This low-pass filter being allowed to be small, it probably is the big primary factor which can do to hold down the price of this camera.
Dynamic range/highlightAt the time of Nikon D2X, being able to guarantee the sufficient dynamic range in the open part of 5.5 microns which pass it was insecure, but doing that beautifully, there is a result that it removed. This time it came to the point of having the open part of approximately 6.1 microns with the technical power. Approximately, you can call the power of amount and the light where the number of pixels decreases in approximately 1000 ten thousand pixels vis-a-vis 1200 ten thousand pixels that it became large.
Actually, as for the dynamic range by comparison with Nikon D2X, 1/3 - 1/2 squeezing amount as spread, is visible on highlight side. It arranged the solid where where you place the white gypsum image and white ones where work example had ups and downs mainly on the center on highlight side, is black on shadow side, has the shadow, the black paper

kuankuoyun2002


網路會員

5) 2005/12/15 14:04 
Actually, as for the dynamic range by comparison with Nikon D2X, 1/3 - 1/2 squeezing amount as spread, is visible on highlight side. It arranged the solid where where you place the white gypsum image and white ones where work example had ups and downs mainly on the center on highlight side, is black on shadow side, has the shadow, the black paper Hari, held down reflection on shadow side and in order for contrast to become large, it set. Of course, light facing, from the left hand lighting of one light.
The completely same lens (50 mmF1.8) with it tried photographing respectively. With because direction of the gypsum image a little as for having changed, strikes midway, as for this we want making charm. The picture is small, but the left edge has sprung out with aptitude exposure, with the exposure which highlight is not flying, as for the middle data with D2X highlight. But, with the same exposure D200 this has been settled within the proper half. The picture the right as expected is over, but it will not be suddenly to lose condition, it probably will understand that it becomes the gradation. Nikon D2X squeezes and is the aptitude scope of supply 1/3 - 2/3, but as for Nikon D200 securely it understands to 1 contraction amount that the aptitude range is spreading. Just, you probably can say that 200 ten thousand pixels of the resolution impression, looked back in the dynamic range.
This difference when Nikon Capture 4.4 is used, furthermore becomes remarkable, securely the picture which is 1 contraction over enters into aptitude inside. Work example when photographing is something which is exposed overly, but -2/3 it was possible to recover the white of the dress securely with the revision of step. You can say that the Daigo taste oven of RAW data use it is one it spread.Dynamic range/shadowIt can decide also shadow side with the same picture. The part where the inside of the black bottle is black is the expectation where almost light does not enter. But, is gradation information is maintained with even cutting which held down in the limit which highlight does not fly. 1/3 it squeezes even on shadow side and as been able to have the close scope of supply, it can think. We want observing to the position of peak of the shadow in the histogram. Of course these 2 contraction values are the same.Of course, it is possible furthermore to pull information from the RAW data and to extend. As for work example those which using the exposure revision of additional RAW adjustment, 1.3 contraction extent revise those which purposely are exposed to the under eye brightly. With this there are no either times when it is bothered in noise.Color reproducibilityIf mode II is used, it has the reappearance power which is equal to Nikon D2X. Rather than with saying, mode II in order with all cameras to become the same tendency as Nikon, it probably will be tuned. Mode I, and mode III, especially mode III furthermore high chroma changed in expression, but in order to hold down the crop in the high chroma limits skillfully, it is discovered. Being lively, you should have said probably that it is difficult to lose gradation. This by comparison with D70 s is desirable tendency.
In addition, the feature that the data of analog state balancing it does this camera before the Nikon unique Analogue-to-digital conversion, is succeeded. Because of that, even if being the RAW data, it is correct in advance, if (or you take) the white balance of approximation, it is possible to obtain the color information where the partners with the fluorescent light that, that, noise are few with light bulb light, have ノビ. When this is not done, it cannot obtain the optimum result in especially light bulb light and the fluorescent light illuminant. As for work example with AdobeRGB mode II after the photographing those which in sRGB profile are converted.

kuankuoyun2002


網路會員

6) 2005/12/15 14:05 
Long haul exposure qualityIt is the problem how it processes noise and the missing part which are accumulated to the generally known image sensor, but problem is collected even here the そ without. To 8 seconds the long second time turning noise removal to ON, waiting after the photographing is not found does not occur and, especially problem. When 10 seconds are crossed over, noise cancel starts, but it reached the point where is sufficient time about of half of actual photographing time. It turns this switch to ON and usually, probably there are no kind of times when stress depends on photographing even to the cartridge. As for work example with the sample at the time of 30 second, those where the left the long second time photographed noise removal with ON. Very carefully when you try seeing, there is a mark of revision in several places.
Furthermore, this sample is easy to understand, after the sea urchin photographing the tone curve raising, it has made bright.High sensitivity qualityThis picture is something which was photographed in Nikon D200 Special Live, permission is obtained especially for this report.

Download is possible, but diversion is not possible with other purpose.
From Nikon D200 1600 was added to ISO sensitivity. Until now, as high1, as a sensitivity that this time it clearly writes that they are the sensitivity limits which are not clearly written, it can think that it is the appearance of the self-confidence. Of course up to 400 sufficiently beautifully it reappears from sensitivity 100. Even with sensitivity 800 the normality [ completely there is no problem in the snap ]. Gradation reappearance has done the reappearance which is beautifully sufficient up to 1600, in order high1 (3200 suitable) with a little for the reappearance limits to become narrow, think, also the edge a little it becomes uncertain, if..., this it is the sensitivity 3200 suitable picture, complaint you will attach, but you think that it is not. The plate being attached impression starts appearing a little from sensitivity 800, with 1600 - 3200 clearly starts. Nevertheless, the attitude which whether even with this brushes up shadow noise should be appraised, but the り passed quickly a little the writer and with felt.By the way, you had borrowed in the past, the picture of the β beta machine is increased to comparison, but as for me noisy does not think under any condition with this. Rather than with saying, in order by the fact that noise rides in the shadow section moderately, to be connected to also material feeling, you can think. Here scratching too much, the work becomes necessary the stripe uninformed, in order to acquire material feeling, of adding noise specially. If (gradation has been reproduced securely, it is not necessary to designate those as the air. In other words, you can call the picture which was really photographed with sensitivity 1600) that it is the problem which happens at the time of the high sensitivity where description of the shadow section becomes sweet it has reproduced to the texture of the cloth, sensitivity of sensitivity 1600 you cannot think at all. As for this you can call the same thing in regard to 3200.
It can do to fly to the picture of pixel identical dimensions ] the picture which is surrounded [ with the boundary line ] of blue when it clicks, [.The camera as a machineOf course, the completion impression of that appearance has, but as for here comparison is not possible as expected equally to Nikon D2X. Speaking amount, on the other hand by comparison with D70, it should call that it has become good to here.
Range of vision ratio approximately 95%, high powered finder of 0.94 times
Those where the technology which is cultivated with Nikon F6 is utilized are this finder. Range of vision ratio says a little small inclination, wants paying attention to the size of magnification ratio. Truly it is the brightly easy to see finder. The area of this you probably can say that as expected

kuankuoyun2002


網路會員

7) 2005/12/15 14:06 
Range of vision ratio approximately 95%, high powered finder of 0.94 times
Those where the technology which is cultivated with Nikon F6 is utilized are this finder. Range of vision ratio says a little small inclination, wants paying attention to the size of magnification ratio. Truly it is the brightly easy to see finder. The area of this you probably can say that as expected it is the professional cheerful. In order that the silver salt user which remains very lastly at Nikon is taken in digitally the camera which was developed it seems, has the completion impression of that appearance.

Shutter, in addition
High accuracy, loading the shutter unit which proves high durability with the release test of 10 ten thousand times. Adopting solidity and the lightweight magnesium alloy to the body. Also the mirror shock is held down with the shadow. High-speed starting approximately 0.15 second release time lag approximately 50ms. There is no complaint. In addition, the sealing was done to everywhere of the body which begins the joint, quite high drip-proof efficiency and dustproof efficiency were actualized, but being not to be the submarine camera carefulness. (The け doing, you do not have to throw to underwater that way) adopting wide field of vision angular type the large-sized low temperature polysilicon TFT liquid crystal monitor of adoption 2.5 type in the rear liquid crystal. This and it is easy to see truly. Being the bright place with this, to rub it becomes easy also the っ it is good, but....

11 point ranges
Those where it has become the wide range are う れ forcing thing. The range point spread, it became possible to adjust focus to the face of the model. It is regrettable, the unevenness く when also both sides encounter the cross sensor, is more delightful, but.... Then I agree upon already even at 5 ten thousand increase in yen value value. Though it comes and the れ with problem of sensor size, this time seems that is waived. If smaller cross sensor is developed, perhaps this desire the Kanai う.

Hold impression
It is small, conveniently "it is heavy". If this with important thing, does not have the weight in approximately the body, when acquiring high powered zoom and the bright lens, balance it cannot come off by any means, becomes the front stooping. If [ the snap ] it is exclusive use, also lightness probably is important, but if it is the camera which is used in work, approximately weight is needed. Whether or not the weight, 562 g the best there probably is also a personal equation, but,

Built-in Strobo
Strobo commander function was loaded, the built-in flash. Remote to 2 groups (the auxiliary light) it corresponds to the advanced wireless lighting which is controlled with the wireless master (the main light) as. Approximately 12 (ISO100 m and 20 ℃) with, covering guide number the angle of view of the 18mm lens. Furthermore, the リピーティング radiation which is convenient to multiplex exposure photographing and the modeling radiation which can verify the effect of lighting light in advance are possible. It may show power at the time and the like of collection of data location.

Battery
New development リチャージャブルバッテリー of lithium ion. Basically present D70 and D70s it is the じ, but the ま does not operate with the potato. Because of that, in the battery of D70 and D70s it does not operate. (As for opposite you say that it is possible) it can photograph approximately 1800 scenes with the charge of 1 time. It builds in IC to the battery, itself at the time of full charge remaining capacity of the battery for (%), frequency of total photographing from previous charge, and it is possible to indicate degree of deterioration in the liquid crystal monitor. However there is no discharge function in the charger. It is improbable as for D70 compared to because of the image sensor which consumes electricity, about D70 for the battery to have.

Lens
AF-S DX VR Zoom Nikkor ED 18 - 200mm F3.5 - 5.6G (IF)
The DX ニッコールレンズシ

kuankuoyun2002


網路會員

8) 2005/12/15 14:07 
Lens
AF-S DX VR Zoom Nikkor ED 18 - 200mm F3.5 - 5.6G (IF)
The DX ニッコールレンズシリーズ first high powered zoom lens which in the zoom limits of approximately 11 times covers to telephoto from wide angle. To tell the truth this is the lens which the writer made.
When with you say, it is presumptuous, but because at the time of the impression of NikonD2X, as for especially open F value there is no bright necessity, small size (that) covers the standard limits with the DC lens, we want the VR lens. Of course, if you think of combination 焦 precision, if with the ultrasonic motor, possibility from wide side 18mm telephoto 100 mm. If possibility if it is up to 180 - 200 mm, it was something where it can cover the majority of snap photographing at one. Usually, if there are 18 - 100 mm, there is no problem, but, but when with wedding and the like having been concerned with the admission mouth, just a little just the scene where we would like to take rise it is good, always inserting 200mm of the single unit in the one pocket because of that, attaching to the sub camera it reaches, when this solves with zoom, it is rather grateful. The speed impression is different anyhow. It is the good thing づ く め that it keeps attaching the bright standard lens it is possible in the sub camera. Especially 200mm side what kind of the bright lens compared to, whether VR is attached, whether it is not attached, as for the value lens and somewhere the way, the possible lens which can use with just bright outside those there is a difference of the big merit.
This lens commercialized my request that way. Though the あ it is not to be crushing, it probably has similar request even from many ones. Even in the world of reporting and sport you are welcomed it is not different. Though when you mention 11 time zoom, because it is it is the specification which is not, rather than barrel type of wide angular side (with saying, the subordinate), from center betting on telephoto, the bobbin is enormous in that appearance. So supplying that, that excessively certain ones, you think it exists as a value of this lens.
It is effective to photographing and the telephoto photographing time at the place where VR shows the hand blurring revision effect of approximately 4 steps furthermore with VRII which evolved, is dark. Actually it tried photographing, but with rise of 200mm side 50% has stopped securely even with 1/60. Without purchasing it is the lens which does not enter.
As for this picture Nikon D200 Special Live2 putting, it is something which it photographed. For this report permission is obtained especially.
Download is possible, but diversion is not possible with other purpose.
While on 200mm side changing shutter speed from 1/160 up to 1/60, photographing. With 1/160 there are no most hand being off-center, with 1/60 as for 50% being able to acquire the active data they were surprised to is.Special Thanks Hiroko Koshino Design OfficeThe picture which was increased here the Japanese fashion weak putting, being something which photographed Shaw コシノヒロコ, has obtained permission especially for this report.
Download is possible, but diversion is not possible with other purpose.
This picture is something which was photographed in Nikon D200 Special Live, permission is obtained especially for this report.

Download is possible, but diversion is not possible with other purpose.

kuankuoyun2002


網路會員

9) 2005/12/15 14:15 
請由 http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/read.asp?forum=1021&message=16262664 點入babelfish翻譯內文圖文並茂列出D200 VS D2X的比較.

小小乖


網路會員

10) 2006/04/23 20:54 
大陸的網站評D200 VS D2X,就像F100與F5一樣,差異不大了。

bojain


網路會員

11) 2006/04/24 01:56 
D2X沒有直條紋的問題吧?!
如果差價兩萬~三萬我是根本不會考慮D200的!
但F5 vs F100好像不是這樣~~~

kuankuoyun2002


網路會員

12) 2006/04/24 09:24 
Re: Considering a D2X to substitute my D200... What about noise?
Wheely - 2 months ago
I agonized over this as well when I found my D200 has long banding. I did a fair bit of research and came to the following conclusions.

The D200 has better noise characteristsics that the D2X but that the D2X isn't that bad. The D2X has better white balance than the D200 but the D200 is pretty damn good. In nearly every other respect, the D200 and the D2X are just fine cameras with not too much between them.

For me the choice ended up like this.



D2X - 100% viewfinder coverage, HSC mode at 8fps BUT no flash commander, big and heavy and expensive.

D200 - Remote flash commander, much cheaper, I already have it BUT not 100% viewfinder coverage.

I'm sure there are other differences that appeal to different people but although I'd really love to have 100% viewfinder coverage I felt that without flash commander I'd end up first with a cord, then an SU-800 and then another SB800 just to get the flash nice on the D2X.

Then, while out taking shots of birds I was asked by someone if I could take a shot of them and suddenly I had a use for the D200 pop up flash as my SB800 was safely at home.

Juts some random thougths which may or may not help.

Regards

http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/readflat.asp?forum=1021&message=17183739

kuankuoyun2002


網路會員

13) 2006/04/24 09:27 
Nikon D2X vs. The Nikon D200 - Which Camera is Best for Me?

http://www.digitaldarrell.com/Review-D2xVsD200.asp

godworld


網路會員

14) 2006/10/28 11:40 
http://kamerabild.mkf.se/ArticlePages/200512/14/20051214162333_ADF128/blogg-testbild-d2x_s.jpg

http://kamerabild.mkf.se/ArticlePages/200512/14/20051214162333_ADF128/blogg-testbild-d200_s.jpg

由圖觀之,D2X擁有更多的細節,從中間淺白色那棟建築物的牆面來看,D2X可以表現強面的紋理、材質,而D200只有一片乳白。不明白是否是D200原始設定銳利度偏低的關係,最明顯處是左方類似咖啡色的建築物,他們磚塊紋路和那兩個長方形窗戶的窗簾,都沒有具象地表現出來,甚者D200這張圖檔使用軟體遮色片銳利化,恐怕也顯示不出窗簾的白色橫條紋,我覺得很多窗戶的窗簾D200都好像耀光而喪失細節,不曉得兩機是否為同一鏡頭所拍攝呢?

jenhoxen


網路會員

15) 2006/10/29 00:56 
其他很多討論巳談過D200的問題; 一般認為D200在CCD前的濾鏡太強(一說太多)除雜訊/摩耳紋時,也將細節除掉了.
回上一層 第1頁 / 共1頁 到第 1
手札小舖熱門商品
【台灣私房景點全集】共5冊,合購73折再贈進口黑卡
【我的夢幻人像鏡】2013最新增訂版!
【Nikon DX 達人聖經】手札聖經系列重出江湖!
【駕馭數位單眼相機】貫通攝影的最佳教本!
【2013攝影年鑑】年度新書隆重上市!
攝影家手札數位影像坊DV哈燒網KeyBuy藝廊論壇
服務信箱:242204 新莊副都心郵局第12信箱 │ 會員服務部:02-85215082(上班時間早上9點~下午6點) 和平東路三段276號 │ 廣告專線:0937-887229 │ 總瀏覽1312649309人 │ 線上1718人
攝影家手札科技有限公司 版權所有 © 2017 PhotoSharp All Rights Reserved. 非經許可,請勿任意轉載、出版本站內容